Cooperative Relative Navigation of Multiple Aircraft in GPS-Denied/Degraded Environment Skip to main content
Technologies

Cooperative Relative Navigation of Multiple Aircraft in GPS-Denied/Degraded Environment

GPS-Denied/Degraded

ID: 2020-021 Cooperative Relative Navigation of Multiple Aircraft in GPS-Denied/Degraded Environment

Reach out to us directly to learn more about this technology - Phone: (801) 422-6266

Invention Market Information
Commercialization and Marketing Report
Entrepreneur Plan

I. Market Analysis and Opportunity

  • Target Market: The primary targets for this technology include:
    • Military and defense organizations: These groups require precise navigation in GPS-denied environments for various operations.
    • Emergency response and disaster relief agencies: These organizations need reliable navigation for search and rescue missions, particularly where GPS infrastructure is compromised.
    • Commercial drone operators: This sector includes companies in agriculture, surveying, mapping, and delivery services that need precise navigation even with limited GPS.
    • Aerospace industry: These companies need improved navigation for their unmanned aerial systems (UAS) and other autonomous systems.
    • Research institutions: These organizations require reliable navigation for various scientific expeditions and data gathering.
    • Logistics and delivery services: Companies require precise navigation for drone delivery services in urban environments.
    • Exploration and mining companies: These industries need navigation for mapping and monitoring remote locations.
  • Market Trends: Key trends driving demand for this technology include:
    • Increased use of autonomous systems: There's a growing need for reliable navigation in various industries.
    • Military and defense applications: There is a demand for technologies that enable operations in GPS-denied environments.
    • Advancements in swarm robotics: The technology's decentralized approach is suitable for coordinating multiple vehicles.
    • Resilience against jamming and spoofing: The technology addresses the need for secure systems that don't rely on potentially compromised GPS.
    • Urban air mobility (UAM): The technology supports navigation in complex urban environments.
    • Environmental monitoring and disaster response: Reliable navigation is vital for effective responses when infrastructure is compromised.
  • Market Size: The market for GPS-denied navigation is substantial and growing, driven by increased use of UAS, military needs, and the expansion of urban air mobility.
    • Total Addressable Market (TAM): This includes military, commercial aviation, emergency services, and research sectors.
    • Serviceable Available Market (SAM): This focuses on regions with high military spending, supportive drone regulations, and areas prone to natural disasters.
    • Serviceable Obtainable Market (SOM): This involves early adoption by defense contractors, drone manufacturers, and pilot projects with emergency services.
  • Competitive Landscape: The market includes alternative solutions such as advanced inertial navigation systems (INS), radar, and satellite-based augmentation systems (SBAS). However, the technology’s unique combination of cooperative strategies and decentralized processing provides a competitive edge. The core innovation lies in its ability to provide precise navigation without reliance on GPS, using cooperative communication and decentralized processing.
  • Barriers to Entry: The main barriers to entry include:
    • Technical complexity: This technology requires expertise in various complex fields.
    • High R&D costs: The development of complex systems requires significant investments.
    • Intellectual property: Existing patents may restrict new entrants.
    • Integration challenges: Integrating different components into a cohesive system can be difficult.
    • Communication infrastructure: Establishing reliable communication networks is crucial for the operation of the technology.
    • Testing and validation: Rigorous testing is needed to validate system performance.
    • Regulatory hurdles: Compliance with aviation regulations can be challenging.
    • Scalability concerns: Maintaining accuracy when scaling to larger fleets is complex.

II. Product Development and Technical Strategy

  • Technology Maturity: The technology is estimated to be at a Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of 6 or 7, indicating that it has been tested in relevant environments and could be ready for full-scale demonstration.
  • Key Technical Features:
    • Multi-layer framework: This includes front-end estimation (EKF-based odometry) and back-end optimization (graph-based structure).
    • Cooperative communication: Aircraft share odometry data and calculate relative ranges using opportunistic protocols.
    • Inter-vehicle measurements and coordinated reset: This enhances the accuracy of relative positioning.
    • Decentralized approach: This makes the system scalable and robust to limited bandwidth.
    • Visual-inertial odometry (VIO): This uses monocular cameras and IMUs to estimate motion accurately.
  • Further Development:
    • Enhance robustness and reliability: The system needs thorough testing under various environmental conditions.
    • Optimize scalability: Algorithms must be optimized to handle larger aircraft swarms.
    • Develop sophisticated communication protocols: The technology needs protocols that adapt to changing bandwidths and latencies.
    • Ensure interoperability: Compatibility with different UAS needs to be ensured.
    • Address legal and regulatory compliance: Aviation regulations must be met, especially for autonomous operations.
    • Develop user interfaces: Intuitive interfaces for operators are essential.
    • Optimize costs: Reduction of costs associated with hardware components is essential.
    • Improve real-time processing: Leveraging hardware acceleration can improve speed.
    • Implement robust security measures: Protection against cyber threats like spoofing or jamming attacks is critical.
    • Conduct extensive field trials: Real-world data should be gathered to refine algorithms and validate system performance.
  • Intellectual Property Strategy:
    • Secure patents: File patents for algorithms, methods of cooperative communication, and unique system architectures.
    • Protect trade secrets: Keep proprietary algorithms and processes confidential.
    • Copyright software code: Protect the expression of ideas within the code.
    • Consider trademarking: Register any names, logos, or branding associated with the navigation system.
  • Freedom-to-Operate (FTO): Conduct comprehensive patent searches to ensure the technology does not infringe on existing IP.

III. Business Model and Sales Strategy

  • Pricing Strategy:
    • Value-based pricing: Price based on the value to the customer (e.g., safety, operational efficiency).
    • Tiered pricing: Offer different levels of service and capability.
    • Subscription model: Charge recurring fees for continuous updates and support.
    • Licensing fees: Charge for integrating the technology into existing systems.
    • Usage-based pricing: Charge based on the usage of the technology.
    • Bundling: Combine the technology with other products or services.
    • Custom solutions pricing: Charge custom rates based on complexity and integration requirements.
  • Sales Channels:
    • Direct sales: Target government contracts, defense departments, and research institutions.
    • Distributors and resellers: Partner with aerospace equipment distributors and technology integrators.
    • OEM partnerships: Collaborate with original equipment manufacturers in the aerospace industry.
    • Technology alliances: Partner with companies that offer complementary technologies.
    • Industry events and trade shows: Showcase the technology at events like those hosted by AUVSI.
    • Online channels and digital marketing: Develop an online presence with case studies and webinars.
    • Consultancy services: Offer customization of the navigation system according to customer needs.
    • Pilot programs and demonstrations: Conduct demonstrations and pilot programs for key stakeholders.
  • Business Models:
    • Licensing: License the technology to aerospace manufacturers and defense contractors.
    • Subscription: Offer updates, support services, and cloud-based enhancements on a subscription basis.
    • Product sales: Integrate the technology into new navigation systems and sell it as a product.
    • Service contracts: Charge for installation, maintenance, and updates of navigation systems.
    • Consulting services: Monetize expertise by providing integration and optimization advice.
    • Government and military contracts: Seek funding from government agencies and military organizations.
    • Partnerships with aviation industry players: Collaborate on joint ventures to improve air traffic management.
    • Training programs: Develop training programs for operators and engineers.
    • Data monetization: If permissible, sell anonymized flight data.

IV. Financial Strategy

  • Funding Requirements:
    • R&D: Significant investment is needed for further technology development and testing.
    • Prototyping: Costs associated with building and testing prototypes on actual aircraft.
    • Certification and compliance: Costs related to navigating regulatory requirements.
    • Manufacturing setup: Costs for establishing production lines and quality control measures.
    • Marketing and business development: Resources needed for marketing and building partnerships.
    • Customer support infrastructure: Setting up systems for training and post-deployment support.
    • Intellectual property protection: Costs for securing patents and other forms of IP.
    • Contingency funds: Allocating funds for unforeseen challenges and delays.
    • Commercialization: Commercialization could require several million dollars of funding over multiple years.
  • Funding Sources:
    • Government grants: Explore SBIR/STTR programs and other funding from agencies such as DARPA, NASA, NSF, and DoD.
    • International funding bodies: Look into EU programs like Horizon Europe and the European Defence Fund.
    • Private sector funding: Seek partnerships or funding from aerospace companies, venture capital firms, and industry consortia.
    • Academic and research institutions: Check for internal grants and industry partnerships.
    • Non-profit organizations: Some non-profits may fund projects with societal benefits.
  • Recurring Revenue Opportunities:
    • Maintenance contracts: Offer regular hardware and software checks.
    • Support services: Provide tiered support packages and training.
    • Software upgrades: Sell upgrades with new functionalities and improvements.
    • Customization services: Tailor the system to specific applications.
    • Data services: Subscription access to data analytics.
    • Licensing agreements: License the technology for use in other industries.
  • Return on Investment (ROI): The technology promises a positive ROI by reducing costs from navigation errors, improving operational efficiency, and creating new market opportunities.
  • Breakeven Analysis: The breakeven period is estimated to be 3-7 years post-commercialization, depending on market dynamics and strategic execution.
  • Financial Risks: Development costs, technological complexity, scalability issues, regulatory compliance, and market adoption pose financial risks. Mitigation strategies include thorough cost-benefit analyses, securing early funding, engaging with regulatory bodies, and investing in continuous improvement.

V. Key Partnerships and Alliances

  • Potential Industry Partners:
    • Aerospace and defense companies: Boeing, Lockheed Martin, and Northrop Grumman.
    • UAV manufacturers: DJI Innovations and Parrot Drones.
    • Communications technology firms: Qualcomm, Ericsson, and Nokia.
    • Automotive industry players: Companies like Tesla or Waymo.
    • Research institutions and universities: Collaborate to further technology development.
    • Government agencies and defense departments: Secure government contracts.
    • Technology startups: Integrate the technology into broader AI-driven navigation systems.
  • Benefits of Partnerships:
    • Shared resources and expertise: Partnerships provide access to capital, manufacturing, and distribution expertise.
    • Risk mitigation: Risks are shared between partners.
    • Market entry: Partners can help navigate regulatory requirements.

VI. Regulatory and Legal Considerations

  • Aviation Safety Regulations: Compliance with FAA and EASA safety standards is essential.
  • Communication Standards: Adherence to radio frequency and spectrum management is necessary, requiring approval from agencies like the FCC.
  • Data Privacy and Security: Secure communication channels and adherence to data privacy regulations, such as GDPR, are required.
  • Certification of Navigation Systems: The technology requires certification to demonstrate reliability and performance under various conditions.
  • Operational Approvals: Specific operational approvals may be necessary from aviation authorities.
  • Environmental Regulations: Compliance with noise pollution regulations and electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) standards may apply.
  • International Coordination: Engagement with global aviation bodies like ICAO might be required, particularly near borders or over international waters.

VII. Exit Strategy

  • Potential Exit Strategies:
    • Acquisition by a major aerospace or defense company: This provides an opportunity to leverage existing market presence.
    • Strategic merger with a complementary technology firm: Mergers offer shared resources and market access.
    • Initial Public Offering (IPO): A public offering can provide the company with capital to grow while offering investors opportunities for return.

Phase 1: Technical and Market Validation (6-12 Months)

  • Step 1: Deepen Technical Understanding
    • Goal: Solidify expertise on the core technology, including the multi-layer framework for relative navigation, the Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) for real-time odometry, the graph-based structure for global position optimization, and the cooperative communication protocols.
    • Actions: Review the existing publications, particularly the dissertation by Gary Ellingson, and any related codebases. Work to understand the nuances of the algorithms and their implementation. Seek guidance from the inventors or relevant professors if needed.
  • Step 2: Conduct Focused Market Research
    • Goal: Identify specific target markets and their needs.
    • Actions:
      • Prioritize initial markets: Given the nature of the tech, focus on the military and defense sectors, emergency response, and commercial drone operators.
      • Engage potential customers: Conduct interviews with stakeholders in these sectors to understand their pain points, current solutions, and requirements for GPS-denied navigation.
      • Analyze existing solutions: Review the weaknesses of competitor offerings, to highlight the tech's unique advantages.
  • Step 3: Develop a Minimum Viable Prototype (MVP)
    • Goal: Create a functional prototype to demonstrate the core technology.
    • Actions:
      • Start small: Begin with a limited-scope implementation, perhaps focusing on a simulation environment, or a single drone communicating with recorded data.
      • Emphasize key features: Focus on demonstrating the core functions of real-time odometry using the EKF, the back-end graph optimization for improving global positioning, and the opportunistic communication between vehicles.
      • Document results: Quantify the improvements in navigation accuracy and robustness compared to existing methods.
  • Step 4: Secure Seed Funding
    • Goal: Obtain initial funding to support further development.
    • Actions:
      • Target relevant grants: Apply for SBIR/STTR grants focusing on defense needs and commercialization potential, or other grants from NASA or NSF.
      • Explore seed funding: Pitch the project to angel investors or venture capital firms interested in aerospace and robotics technologies.
      • Highlight dual-use applications: Emphasize both military and civilian applications to appeal to diverse funders.

Phase 2: Product Development and Testing (12-24 Months)

  • Step 5: Refine the Prototype
    • Goal: Address identified limitations and enhance the MVP's robustness.
    • Actions:
      • Iterate based on feedback: Incorporate the feedback from potential customers and early tests.
      • Improve algorithms: Optimize the EKF and graph optimization algorithms for better performance in challenging environments.
      • Develop fail-safes: Implement fail-safe mechanisms for scenarios where communication fails or sensor noise is significant.
  • Step 6: Conduct Extensive Testing
    • Goal: Validate the technology in realistic scenarios.
    • Actions:
      • Field trials: Conduct large-scale field trials in various environments to assess performance, robustness, and scalability.
      • Simulate challenging conditions: Test the system under different weather conditions, terrains, and potential obstructions.
      • Collect real-world data: Use collected data to refine algorithms and validate system performance.
  • Step 7: Develop a Business Model
    • Goal: Decide on a viable revenue strategy.
    • Actions:
      • Consider hybrid approach: Combine licensing for core technology with a subscription model for updates and support services.
      • Explore product sales: Consider selling the technology as part of a comprehensive navigation system.
      • Implement tiered pricing: Offer different service tiers based on the capabilities and functionalities provided.

Phase 3: Market Entry and Growth (24+ Months)

  • Step 8: Secure Intellectual Property
    • Goal: Protect the core technology from competitors.
    • Actions:
      • File patents: File patents for innovative aspects of the technology, particularly algorithms used in the EKF, cooperative communication, and graph-based optimization techniques.
      • Consider trade secrets: Protect certain proprietary algorithms or processes as trade secrets.
      • Conduct FTO analysis: Determine if there are existing patents that might block competitor entry.
  • Step 9: Engage Strategic Partners
    • Goal: Build relationships with key players in the target sectors.
    • Actions:
      • Target relevant companies: Partner with aerospace companies, defense contractors, UAV manufacturers, and communication technology firms.
      • Explore joint ventures: Consider joint ventures with companies that have complementary technologies or capabilities.
  • Step 10: Launch Marketing and Sales Efforts
    • Goal: Reach target customers and generate revenue.
    • Actions:
      • Participate in industry events: Attend trade shows and conferences to demonstrate the technology.
      • Utilize online channels: Develop a dedicated website and use digital marketing strategies.
      • Offer pilot programs: Implement pilot programs with key clients to provide proof-of-concept evidence.
      • Secure government contracts: Engage in government procurement processes to bid for contracts.
  • Step 11: Navigate Regulatory Compliance
    • Goal: Ensure compliance with aviation regulations.
    • Actions:
      • Engage with regulatory bodies: Work closely with aviation regulatory bodies like the FAA and EASA to ensure compliance.
      • Obtain necessary certifications: Obtain certifications for the navigation system to demonstrate its reliability and safety.
      • Address privacy concerns: Ensure compliance with data privacy regulations, especially concerning inter-vehicle communication.
  • Step 12: Scale Operations and Seek Further Funding
    • Goal: Scale operations to meet market demand and sustain long-term growth.
    • Actions:
      • Optimize manufacturing: Reduce costs associated with hardware components and explore mass production techniques.
      • Improve real-time processing: Enhance real-time processing by leveraging hardware acceleration or edge computing solutions.
      • Explore further funding: Seek additional funding from venture capitalists or strategic partners to support expansion.

Key Considerations for Success:

  • Focus on a Specific Niche: Given the complexity of the market, targeting a specific niche within the broader sector (e.g., military drones) may prove more effective.
  • Emphasize the Unique Value Proposition: Highlight the technology’s decentralized approach, cooperative communication, and robust performance in GPS-denied environments.
  • Be Agile and Adaptable: The market is constantly evolving, so the ability to adapt to changing needs is crucial.
  • Prioritize Strong Customer Relationships: Building strong relationships with early adopters and strategic partners will be critical for market validation and adoption.
  • Maintain a Strong IP Portfolio: Continuous IP protection is essential to ensure a long term competitive advantage.